Now, a recent Reddit thread might have uncovered the answer. The bad news? Women do prefer one type over the other. The good news? It's not a deal breaker.
According the poll, almost 75 per cent of women preferred uncircumcised penises and that was based on their experiences with both.
One user, st12ly18, suggests the skin is much more enjoyable: "Up until 2 years ago, i would have 100% said circumcised but now that i know that the one experience I had with an uncircumcised on in my early 20s was NOT the norm and due to poor hygiene, i totally love and prefer uncircumcised. There's something so sexy about it and they're fun to please and play with!"
Another subscriber suggested she's tried both and there was no doubt with her preference: "I've experienced about a 50/50 split, and all other things being equal, I prefer uncircumcised." Another, polelifeandpussy, agreed, arguing "uncircumcised is so much better."
If you're feeling like this might be the end of the world, there's reason to breathe a sigh of relief. While uncircumcised received the majority of support, some Redditers preferred circumcised.
And although many cheered in favour of untouched skin, they also pointed out that it's "not going to ruin the mood and (she won't) stop if it's not" and" it wouldn't be a deal breaker."
If you're interested to find out more on what females really think of your pork sword, check out what women really think about the size of your penis.