Co-host Phoebe Timmins, who was appeared in the same season of Survivor: All Stars as Genat, pushed further, asking the former model, "Are you saying you're bad in bed?"
"Probably right now I am", he replied, suggesting his libido had suffered after taking part in two consecutive seasons.
Interestingly, Sarah Tileke – the other half of the podcast and also a Survivor alumni – joined in suggesting women experienced the complete opposite on the island.
"At least when I played, the girls, somehow everything was activated on the island. Everything operated on a high buzzy level," she added.
"Almost every guy without fail said nothing's working."